All Risk Policy

Back up, overflow, leak, or flood: What's the difference?

If you've had damage in your home caused by water, it literally pays to know the difference in the words you use.

Many homeowners have found themselves in the unfortunate position of discovering water in their home causing damage. A homeowner with this type of damage may have said "my home is flooded!" or "I had a back up," or "there's sewage everywhere!"

These words have different meanings to different people and unfortunately, using them in the wrong way can mean the difference in whether or not coverage is afforded for your claim. 

It's best to let an experienced public adjuster like the ones at VIP Adjusting guide you through this potential minefield, but here are the basics of what you might need to know if you've found yourself with water damage.

 
Water damage from shower

What types of damage does the typical insurance policy cover? 

The two most common types of insurance policies for homeowners in Florida are HO-3 and DP-3 policies, known as "all risk" insurance policies. These types of insurance policies usually cover all sudden and accidental damage, and then reduce that coverage through various exclusions. All-risk insurance policies normally cover water damage caused by plumbing leaks, and access to repair the damaged plumbing. 

Some HO-3 and DP-3 policies and some insurance companies have exclusions for all types of water damage, including plumbing leaks, or may have a cap on plumbing leaks with a special limit of liability, usually $5,000 or $10,000. For the purposes of this article, we are assuming these caps or exclusions are not in place. 

A less common insurance policy in Florida, even though it's often not much cheaper, is an HO-8 policy, which works in the opposite way of an all-risk policy. An HO-8 policy is often referred to as a "named perils" policy. Instead of starting with all sudden and accidental, or "fortuitous" losses, an HO-8 policy starts with no coverage and adds in only certain named perils, usually wind and hail, civil commotion and riot, smoke, aircraft, vehicles, volcano, explosion, vandalism and theft. Those losses are then even further excluded. This type of policy also does not cover plumbing leaks, at all. 

So where does that leave us with our water damage? What's a back up? What's an overflow? What's a leak? What's a flood? Which of them do my insurance policy cover if I have water damage?

Water damage caused by "back ups"

My toilet backed up and disgusting water is everywhere causing damage. Surely that's a "back up," right? Nope! A leak from your toilet is actually covered under an all-risk policy, whether there was a plumbing break or failure, or even if you just had a clog.

The language that excludes a "back up" in an insurance policy often reads "We [the insurance company] do not cover water damage caused by water which backs up through sewers or drains..."

Well, what about if water backs up from the drain in my sink or tub? Surely THAT is a "back up" then? Nope, wrong again. 

Florida's courts, in analyzing the language of insurance policy have held that back ups of sewers or drains are damages caused by water that has backed up from a leak originating off the property. The sewer is the ultimate destination of water that leaves your property, so a failure of plumbing off the property, or water coming from the actual sewer is a "back up" that wouldn't be covered under the insurance policy. The same goes for drains. A storm drain in the street would be a "drain" under your insurance policy, or perhaps, a drainage ditch would be a drain that would be excluded.

Otherwise, your insurance policy is meant to cover losses caused by water accidentally escaping from plumbing systems and appliances in your home, without distinguishing whether that water is coming or going. 

Water damage caused by an "overflow"

Along the same lines of water damage caused by a back up is water damage caused by an overflow. Overflows are often referenced in an insurance policy as water which overflows from a sump pump. If you have a pump meant to keep water out of your home and it is overpowered or overwhelmed, then water will have been deemed to "overflow." The same would hold true for exterior drains. If they've overflowed and result in water that ends up in your house, that would normally be excluded under your insurance policy.

An overflow is not, however, when water escapes from your toilet, your sink, or your tub. These are plumbing leaks and would be covered under a standard all-risk policy. 

Water damage caused by a "leak"

Plumbing leaks are a bit of a catch-all coverage under your all-risk insurance policy, because they are sudden and accidental leaks. Air conditioner and HVAC leaks are covered like this, as well. Depending on the insurance company, some all-risk policies in Florida still cover roof leaks as well. 

The provisions in the insurance policy often exclude repair to the system or appliance the water escaped from, meaning the repair to the plumbing, HVAC or roof is usually not covered, unless it was also damaged by a covered loss. If it failed because of old age, the system isn't covered, but if the roof was damaged by a hurricane, it is covered. The water, then, is what's often referred to as an "ensuing loss."

The all-risk policies that don't cover roof leaks have language that says something like it excludes damage caused by rain "unless the exterior of the building" is first damaged by either a "covered peril," or sometimes more narrowly and specifically by wind or hail. 

Water damage caused by a "flood"

This is the term that trips up most homeowners. "My house was flooded." "I came home to a flood." Flood is not covered by standard homeowners insurance policies because "flood" is a very specific term for water, outside the home, on the ground covering more than a certain area of land. A rising river is a flood. Storm surge is a flood. Abnormally high tide is a flood. Rain water in a low lying area is a flood. The rain storm that carried Noah's ark was a flood. 

An air conditioner leak is not a flood. A plumbing leak is not a flood. A roof leak is not a flood. 

Because of this difference, and some further limiting language in insurance policies, pretty much any water on the ground outside the home is not covered. An abnormally wet ground from heavy rains that exerts pressure on a foundation, or poor drainage are not covered. 

Flood insurance is usually a separate policy under the National Flood Insurance Program, administered by FEMA and the Federal Government.

If you've found yourself with water causing damage to your home in Tequesta, Jupiter, Hobe Sound, or anywhere else in Florida's Treasure Coast or Space Coast, it's best to consult with an experienced public adjuster like VIP Adjusting before your insurance company tries to trip you up in a recorded statement. Call today or contact us for a free claim evaluation.

You might also be interested in:

More about plumbing leaks

Flood claims

Cast Iron Plumbing Claims

Plumbing Leaks: What’s covered by your insurance policy?

What does your homeowners insurance cover if you have a plumbing leak?

 

There are several different types of insurance policies for homeowners (both residential and rental properties) as well as for commercial properties. Today we’re going to discuss what is typically covered by the most common homeowners insurance policy in Florida, an HO-3 policy, also referred to as an “all risk” policy.

Broken Cast Iron Pipe

What is an HO-3 or “All Risk” Policy?

An HO-3 policy is often referred to as an “all risk” policy because it starts describing the coverage as all damage, either “direct physical loss to property,” or “sudden and accidental loss” and then works backwards from there to limit that coverage with exclusions. As always, you should review the terms of your insurance policy with a public adjuster at VIP Adjusting if you’re making a claim in Fort Pierce, or anywhere throughout the Treasure Coast. 

Some homeowners insurance policies only cover a small list of “named perils” and have limited coverage while some HO-3 homeowners policies don’t cover plumbing leaks at all. With aging homes throughout Florida including aging plumbing, and shoddy materials and workmanship becoming the norm for new construction and renovation, hopefully you’ve checked with your insurance agent before the time comes to make a claim. 

Ensuing Loss and Water Damage are Covered

There are two types of plumbing systems in most Florida homes. Supply plumbing includes pressurized pipes that carry water into your home and to your fixtures and appliances. Sanitary plumbing, or “waste lines” carry used water from your toilets, showers, bath tubs, sinks, washing machines and dishwashers to your septic tank or to the sewer.

If water accidentally escapes from either of these plumbing systems, either because the pipes burst, or a cast iron drain pipe has rusted, all damage that’s caused by the water is covered (unless your policy has a water damage exclusion, but I’ll continue to operate on the assumption that we’re discussing a standard HO-3 policy from here forward).

There must be water damage in order for the loss to be covered. If you have clean water spill onto a tile floor from a broken sink faucet and it causes no damage, there is likely no coverage and no viable insurance claim. 

If the water has caused damage, however, your claim is viable. Water leaks may very easily damage laminate floors or lower quality cabinets and vanities. More substantial supply line leaks can cause tiles to de-bond or crack after swelling and contracting the mortar underneath. Water can also easily damage drywall and baseboards.

If your leak is from a broken waste line or collapsed cast iron drain, the damage is even more serious. Water in sanitary pipes often contains contaminants from your sink or dishwasher (usually referred to as Category 2 water or “grey water”) or actual sewage from toilets (usually referred to as Category 3 water). If these types of water come in contact with any porous building material, it requires special types of repairs, most of which are outlined in publications produced by the Institute of Inspection Cleaning and Restoration Certification, or IICRC, which is the industry standard.

Leak detection

If you’ve discovered water on the floor in your home and it’s causing damage, the investigation to determine the source of the water is often covered. Homeowners insurance policies require you to protect the property from further damage and this activity may be one of the most important undertakings in stemming the losses inside your home. It also requires that you document damages. A leak detection satisfies your requirements and post-loss obligations under your insurance policy.

Sometimes this is a simple undertaking, while other times it’s a more significant investigation. VIP Adjusting can assist you with this portion of your claim and make sure all steps are documented to show your insurance company when the time comes. 

Access to Repair the Plumbing is Covered

In addition to the water damage coverage trigger, your homeowners insurance policy typically covers access to the broken plumbing to allow for repair. Plumbing access isn’t often the first thought of a homeowner, but it can easily be the most expensive portion of a claim. 

If a supply pipe bursts inside the wall of your bathroom, the water cleanup and repair of water damage may be minimal, but in order to get to the leaking pipe to repair it, you may have to demolish an expensive shower, including removing and likely damaging the tile. 

If a supply pipe is leaking inside the slab of a home carrying water to the kitchen, you may have to remove tile or wood flooring to dig through the slab. This is not always the case, though. 

If a cast iron waste line has collapsed inside the slab, there is definitely access required through the floor and the slab. A significant trench may need to be dug throughout the home to lay a significant portion of new pipe, because waste lines often rely on gravity to carry dirty water out of your home. These repairs can run across multiple rooms and may require significant repairs and renovation. 

You also may have continuous flooring running throughout your whole home, or significant portions of it. These are important factors that need to be taken into consideration as part of your claim, and why it’s best to rely on your public adjuster, instead of the insurance company’s adjuster.

Broken Pipes are Usually Not Covered, but might be in some cases

Your insurance policy does not typically cover “loss to the system or appliance” that is the origin of the water leak and damage. That means if your pipes burst, the insurance covers the water damage and the access, but you pay to replace the pipe. Alternatively, if a valve on your dishwasher or washing breaks and leaks, the water damage is covered, but you have to fix or replace the dishwasher or washing machine that is leaking.  This is the most common situation, but it is not always the case.

If you had a supply line inside the slab that is leaking, instead of making a costly repair damaging the flooring and slab, you may be able to make a type of temporary repair known as a re-route. This type of repair has new supply lines run to the location through walls and ceilings (access through drywall and paint is often significantly less expensive than flooring and slab work). 

A plumbing re-route is often determined to be temporary because it doesn’t make you whole and return your property to pre-loss condition. It may or may not be a permanent solution. Sometimes, a re-route reduces your cold water supply by exposing it to heat in exterior walls or attic spaces. Other times, it’s just not feasible, like if the supply line runs to a kitchen island.

There are a lot of different scenarios that come in to play when evaluating damage as a result of a pluming leak. These scenarios have large implications when it comes to the amount of money you’ll ultimately receive to repair your home. It’s important to get in touch with a public adjuster as early on in the process as possible so that you’re protected. 

If you’ve had a plumbing leak in your home, contact VIP Adjusting today for a free claim evaluation.

You might also be interested in:

More information about plumbing leaks and damage

If your plumbing is unusable for a period of time, you may also need to make a claim for additional living expenses.

What if you find mold damage after your plumbing has leaked